€500k pension bill for sitting TDs

Bertie Ahern tops list of sitting TDs who received generous ministerial pensions in 2009 with payment of €98,901

John Downes, News Investigations Correspondent

Ahern €99k

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Former taoiseach Bertie Ahern received a ministerial pension of almost €100,000 last year and is among a host of sitting and former TDs who have continued to receive generous ministerial pensions from the state, Department of Finance figures show.

They reveal former Ceann Comhairle John O'Donoghue TD received a severance payment of more than €18,000 after resigning his seat last October following a series of revelations about his lavish expenses during his time in office.

Despite moves by the government to limit the entitlement of current Oireachtas members to such payments, the figures show some of the best-known politicians in the country were paid tens of thousands of euro in ministerial pensions on top of their TD salaries in 2009.

These payments were made during a year when the government introduced one of the harshest budgets in recent memory, including significant cuts to social welfare payments.

According to the Department of Finance figures, Ahern was paid a ministerial pension totalling €98,901 last year, while former Ceann Comhairle Rory O'Hanlon (Fianna Fáil) was paid €82,355 and Mary O'Rourke of Fianna Fáil received €28,341.

Former Labour leader Ruairi Quinn received €41,656 and Fianna Fáil TD Frank Fahey was paid €37,205, while Dr Michael Woods TD received €33,343 and former Fine Gael leader Michael Noonan received €39,944.

The two main opposition party leaders, Enda Kenny of Fine Gael and Eamonn Gilmore of Labour, received relatively modest payments of €9,113 and €1,181 respectively.

Following legal advice from attorney general Paul Gallagher, the government last year decided it was not constitutionally possible to
reduce payments to sitting TDs by more than 25%. But ministerial pension payments to former Oireachtas members were not reduced.

The figures show how a number of former politicians, including some who have since taken up lucrative jobs in the public and private sectors, were paid generous pensions as former ministers last year.

These include the current EU commissioner Maire Geoghegan Quinn, who received €64,281 in 2009, and her predecessors in that role, Charlie McCreevy (€74,746) and Padraig Flynn (€50,927).

All three are also entitled to lucrative additional pensions as former TDs, as well as any other pension entitlements they would have run up in their subsequent roles.

Disgraced former Fianna Fáil politician and cabinet minister Ray Burke was paid a ministerial pension of €57,455, while Construction Industry Federation chief Tom Parlon received €19,008, the figures show.

Sitting TDs are paid 50% of their full pension entitlement until they leave the Oireachtas. However, under government rules former taoisigh such as Ahern can receive their full ministerial pension while still in office.

A Department of Finance spokesman said the figures, which include any amounts paid to former ministers who may have voluntarily agreed to forgo part or all of their pension, are unaudited and may be subject to "minor change".

The figures also reflect the 25% reduction in payments to serving TDs.

The Pension gravy train - What former ministers received last year *

Serving TDs

Bertie Ahern €98,901
Rory O'Hanlon €82,355
Ruairi Quinn €41,656
Michael Noonan €39,944
Frank Fahey €37,205
Michael Woods €33,343
Mary O'Rourke. €28,341
John McGuinness €25,276
Michael Kitt €25,276
Jimmy Devins €25,273
Jim Mc Daid €22,487
John O'Donoghue €18,481
Michael D Higgins €17,738
Richard Bruton €13,242
Enda Kenny €9,113
Pat Rabbitte €4,255
Eamon Gilmore €1,181

Former TDs

Albert Reynolds. €109,358
Garret FitzGerald €103,926
John Bruton €100,027
Dick Spring €76,932
Charlie McCreevy €74,746
M Geoghegan-Quinn €64,281
Ray Burke €57,455
Desmond O'Malley €56,059
Padraig Flynn €50,927
Alan Dukes €45,470
Ray MacSharry €41,135
Michael McDowell €31,435
Liz O'Donnell €19,167
Tom Parlon €19,008

*Figures may change slightly as they are based on provisional Department of Finance data which has yet to be audited.

February 28, 2010

Comments

#1 Anthony commented, on February 28, 2010 at 8:39 p.m.:

This could only happen in Ireland and that's why the country is bankrupt.High pay and bad government! Only god can save us.
Anthony

#2 Jaker commented, on February 28, 2010 at 9:24 p.m.:

I despaired for this country last week...I fear for it this week!

#3 Charles Healy commented, on February 28, 2010 at 9:25 p.m.:

Why do we put up with this abuse?
Is it something to do with being a former colony?

#4 Roger Rafferty commented, on March 1, 2010 at 10:11 p.m.:

They should all be challenged to give up their pensions if they are still in receipt of state income. This should become a political issue - and if they refuse, then voters can make up their own minds at the next election. Some have retired - or have been retired - from the Dail and there's not much can be done about that. But if they are in receipt of significant income from other sources, why aren't the subject to a means test like ordinary people are when receiving much smaller amounts of public money on social welfare?

#5 joe commented, on March 4, 2010 at 5:59 p.m.:

The rule is "if you pay peanuts you get monkeys", and we certainly don't want monkeys running the country. The fact that politicians get paid nothing like peanuts is the exception that proves the peanut-monkey rule.

#6 Richard commented, on March 4, 2010 at 8:07 p.m.:

A useful CSPE project for 2nd level students would be to put all of this information on classroom walls in large posters.Then assign groups to contact each of these people and query if such generous remunaration was justified considering the legacy left by those who have gone and the inability of the rest to do anything worthwhile.Each response received should be discucssed and analysed and submitted as an indication of the quality of all in receipt of such largess.Remember what Gordon Gekko said in the film "Wallstreet",GREED IS GOOD.

#7 Brian Phelan commented, on March 7, 2010 at 8:34 a.m.:

This really must stop and if the Govt continues to hide behind the Constitution then the people must tackle it at ground level. Everybody who is self-employed must stop paying tax and refuse to comply with the inevitable demands and legal actions that follow. Those on PAYE should explore their rights to register as self-employed and follow the same course. Employers should refuse to administer the PAYE scheme if the self-employment option is not open to their employees. If Govt insists on mis-spending our money then we must withhold it from them until they show themselves to be fit custodians of the public purse.

#8 Caitriona commented, on March 7, 2010 at 11:30 a.m.:

our forefathers fought hard for independence from the British Empire. Now we sit on our backsides and allow our politicians take us for fools and do as they please. Personally, I think that people are so self-absorbed and insular that unless something is going to directly impact upon them, they couldn't give a damn. This is probably true of other countries, but they have a government to step-in and work for the greater good. Unfortunately, our politicians are as self-absorbed and insular as everyone else and nothing else is expected of them. Unfortunately, nothing is going to change until people get some sense.

#9 Danny H commented, on March 7, 2010 at 1:35 p.m.:

I along with 600 other former employees of the once semi state owned Irish fertilizer co. are still waiting some eight years for the remainder of our redundancy monies promised by the then Minister Mary Harney. Corrupt Government through and through. Its about time that the unemployed working class took to the streets marching to dublin from North , South East and west and demand that these politicians stop wasting our tax payers money. Another excuse to go on junkets this St. Patricks Day. People wake up and tell the politicians to take wage cuts and no expenses for going to work, none of the ordinary working people of Ireland get expenses for travelling to work.

#10 colm commented, on March 7, 2010 at 4:08 p.m.:

This information is sickening in relation to what happened to the pensions of the Waterford glass workers and those in SR Technics it is hypocracy of the highest order. Do politicians not realise what they are doing is going to lead to anarcy. They may say that irish people will take whatever is thrown at them, but I feel with all the waste, corruption,
mis-management and economic illiteracy, we the people are very, very angry and we will take to the streets!

#11 jack meskill commented, on March 7, 2010 at 9:27 p.m.:

We are sheep ! We deserve no better. Danny H, look at this quote from todays business post and tell me, after your letter above, if you think we live in a fair democracy? But will you guys still continue to vote for FF or FG candidates at even local elections? Of course you will.
"
IL&P paid more than €4m to former executives
Sunday, March 07, 2010 By David Clerkin
Irish Life& Permanent has paid more than €4 million to former chief executive Denis Casey and two other senior executives who resigned last year after details emerged about the institution’s controversial transactions with Anglo Irish Bank."

#12 DaithiM commented, on March 7, 2010 at 9:36 p.m.:

Why has this taken so long to become an issue and out in the open. All this while the state retirement age is to rise to 68. You couldn't make it up, No wonder they are so out of touch, is this what they call living in the real world, they should try it some time. I would put them all on a ghost estate in Longford on social welfare. To think that the likes of Burke and McDowell get big payouts every year for doing nothing, what a sick joke.

The Pension gravy train - What former ministers received last year *

Serving TDs

Former TDs

Comments

Comments closed

Share this article

Search

This issue 5 years ago

RSS Feeds